Dersh has been a New Yorker since childhood , he doesn’t know New York law? If lawyers are all over the map on the merits of this case, why was it brought?

Because lawyers can be all over the map on any legal issue. In any case, there's going to be lawyers on the other side arguing that the case shouldn't have been brought - and any case that goes to trial is going to have that, because so many criminal cases plea bargain out.

In countless posts on this subject, I don't recall you ever actually engaging with the subject of these arguments. You post links to them, but you never talk about the merits of what their positions are - just that they're critical of the prosecution. Which is your prerogative, of course - you don't actually have to spend any time understanding what these guys are arguing, let alone assessing whether their arguments have any merits. But it's not an effective strategy to try to convince other people of the merits of their arguments without, you know, presenting their arguments rather than just discussing their bios over and over.

US Policy FAQ

---

Contact Shrewd'm
Contact the developer of these message boards.