Hi, Shrewd!        Login  
Shrewd'm.com 
A merry & shrewd investing community
Best Of MIBest OfAll BoardsThe Shrewd’m WeeklyLearn to InvestHow to Become Shrewd
Search
Shrewd'm.com Merry shrewd investors
Search
Best Of MIBest OfAll BoardsThe Shrewd’m WeeklyLearn to InvestHow to Become Shrewd


The week's question
In December 2024, in the thread "Re: BRK: Why Not XOM?", BreckHutHigh asked the members: "What about the long road trips with kids?" This week it is put to everyone again. The button below opens the small thread re-asking it - read what others have said so far, then give your own answer as an ordinary reply.
Answer this questionContinue to Shrewd'mThis note won't appear again
Investment Strategies / Mechanical Investing
Unthreaded | Threaded | Whole Thread (20) |
Author: zeelotes 🐝🐝  😊 😞
Number: of 6132 
Subject: Re: A different way to measure momentum
Date: 07/10/26 4:12 PM
Post New | Post Reply | Report Post | Recommend It!
No. of Recommendations: 22
In the 90s I realized this myself and created a simple way to capitalize on it. On the MI Board some of you may recall that I posted extensively on the fact that the Short Screens created by members did best coming off of a major bottom. In other words, as Jim wrote, what has done the worst leading up to the bottom typically does the best afterward.

In the last two years my consensus indicators identified two major bottoms that were actionable for this strategy - 4/8/2025 and 3/30/2026. So on the date of the signal I simply find the drop of the SPDRs over the previous three months. I then choose to enter the top five based on the ascending sort - in other words, what has done the best is at the bottom, and what has done the worst is at the top. I buy the ones that have done the worst.

4/8/2025 Signal

Date:   4/8/2025                                            Forward  Forward  Forward  Forward  Forward  Forward  Forward  Forward  Forward  Forward  Forward  Past     Past     Past
Symbol Sector 1-Day 3-Day 5-Day 7-Day 10-Day 1-Mth 2-Mths 3-Mths 6-Mths 9-Mths 12-Mths 3-Mths 6-Mths 12-Mths
XOP Spdr S&p Oil & Gas Explor & Product 11.61% 5.55% 4.95% 9.83% 9.50% 14.81% 21.94% 30.09% 33.07% 27.14% 69.77% -25.55% -25.13% -34.64%
XBI Spdr Series Trust Spdr S&p Biotech Etf 7.28% 6.49% 9.66% 8.78% 13.32% 11.81% 20.73% 21.37% 51.11% 77.30% 87.06% -24.38% -28.11% -22.67%
XLK Spdr Select Sector Fund Technology 13.43% 10.36% 11.77% 7.31% 10.19% 21.22% 33.27% 42.83% 62.21% 60.77% 57.94% -23.02% -20.88% -12.24%
XRT Spdr S&p Retail Etf 9.39% 6.76% 5.76% 7.07% 8.44% 14.65% 26.86% 28.82% 36.59% 44.81% 34.00% -21.45% -17.15% -15.64%
XLY Spdr Select Sector Fund Consumer Discretionary 10.89% 7.59% 7.12% 5.14% 7.93% 14.23% 21.28% 23.69% 34.58% 39.67% 25.92% -20.72% -10.08% -1.47%
KRE Spdr S&p Regional Banking Etf 7.83% 0.92% 4.43% 5.35% 9.71% 16.47% 19.46% 30.25% 31.25% 40.49% 41.73% -18.25% -10.75% 2.39%
KBE Spdr S&p Bank Etf 7.33% 1.33% 4.49% 4.89% 8.75% 15.40% 18.56% 28.36% 30.28% 39.58% 37.79% -16.38% -10.64% 2.18%
XME Spdr S&p Metals & Mining Etf 9.70% 10.38% 11.49% 12.29% 13.56% 18.73% 34.10% 40.98% 110.35% 134.39% 132.97% -15.50% -22.11% -21.17%
XLE Spdr Select Sector Fund Energy Select Sector 7.74% 3.21% 3.41% 6.62% 6.28% 6.76% 9.33% 16.76% 18.37% 23.06% 53.34% -12.50% -14.71% -19.02%
XLI Spdr Select Sector Fund Industrial 8.88% 7.95% 8.53% 7.63% 8.39% 16.82% 24.38% 28.25% 34.60% 38.17% 47.08% -12.08% -13.38% -5.83%
XLB Materials Select Sector Spdr 8.74% 8.39% 8.83% 8.72% 9.71% 13.56% 18.98% 23.45% 22.23% 28.60% 40.21% -11.34% -20.58% -18.46%
XLC The Communication Services Select Sector Spdr Fund 8.84% 5.97% 6.94% 4.74% 6.73% 13.41% 20.06% 24.27% 34.98% 36.77% 32.57% -11.19% -4.25% 5.53%
RWR Spdr Dj Wilshire Reit Etf 6.58% 5.13% 7.60% 9.41% 9.64% 11.69% 13.89% 12.80% 16.45% 16.89% 22.50% -10.77% -14.67% -3.38%
XLF Spdr Select Sector Fund Financial 7.54% 6.26% 7.63% 6.22% 8.65% 13.52% 16.12% 19.28% 22.65% 27.46% 16.94% -9.10% -2.39% 6.82%
XLRE Real Estate Select Sector Spdr Fund The 5.74% 4.96% 7.44% 9.09% 9.14% 11.54% 12.89% 12.70% 13.28% 10.13% 15.34% -7.06% -12.96% -0.91%
XLV Spdr Select Sector Fund Health Care 4.35% 2.93% 3.54% 1.89% 2.07% 0.87% 0.88% 1.98% 9.69% 19.53% 13.10% -4.94% -11.66% -5.36%
XLU Spdr Select Sector Fund Utilities 3.94% 4.42% 6.28% 6.40% 7.17% 9.59% 10.37% 11.78% 25.92% 15.65% 28.91% -3.16% -6.62% 14.82%
XLP Spdr Select Sector Fund Consumer Staples 3.88% 5.24% 6.13% 7.23% 7.10% 6.59% 6.85% 7.27% 3.29% 3.57% 9.16% -0.81% -4.59% 5.53%
3-Months - Lowest 5 10.52% 7.35% 7.85% 7.63% 9.88% 15.34% 24.82% 29.36% 43.51% 49.94% 54.94% -23.02% -20.27% -17.33%
3-Months - Lowest 10 9.41% 6.05% 7.16% 7.49% 9.61% 15.09% 22.99% 29.14% 44.24% 52.54% 58.76% -18.98% -17.29% -12.81%
3-Months - Highest 5 5.09% 4.76% 6.20% 6.17% 6.83% 8.42% 9.42% 10.60% 14.97% 15.27% 16.69% -5.01% -7.64% 4.18%
3-Months - Highest 10 6.62% 5.45% 6.63% 6.80% 7.49% 10.44% 13.38% 15.85% 20.15% 21.98% 27.92% -8.30% -10.58% -2.03%


So the ones to buy on 4/9/2025 were: XOP, XBI, XLK, XRT and XLY

This produced an average return of 54.94% over the next twelve months, while the ones that had done the best leading up to the bottom have an average return of 16.69%.

This has happened once again this year, though not nearly as pronounced. Why not? Because the drop leading up to the bottom in April 2025 was way more severe. The greater the severity, the greater the bounce that follows. It's simple math.

3/30/2026

Date:   3/30/2026                                           Forward  Forward  Forward  Forward  Forward  Forward  Forward  Forward  Past     Past     Past
Symbol Sector 1-Day 3-Day 5-Day 7-Day 10-Day 1-Mth 2-Mths 3-Mths 3-Mths 6-Mths 12-Mths
XLK Spdr Select Sector Fund Technology 4.23% 6.66% 7.79% 11.43% 16.03% 25.10% 53.54% 49.60% -12.31% -9.64% 23.77%
XLF Spdr Select Sector Fund Financial 2.10% 2.43% 3.15% 6.14% 7.08% 7.80% 6.35% 11.25% -12.22% -10.54% -1.42%
XLY Spdr Select Sector Fund Consumer Discretionary 3.14% 2.35% 2.00% 6.70% 10.20% 12.01% 11.85% 11.22% -12.21% -11.99% 7.45%
XRT State Street Spdr S&p Retail Etf 2.69% 2.66% 3.63% 7.01% 6.71% 9.45% 6.32% 12.20% -8.79% -9.26% 14.53%
XLC The Communication Services Select Sector Spdr Fund 2.68% 3.46% 3.58% 5.84% 7.97% 7.92% 7.09% -0.51% -8.68% -9.03% 13.13%
XLV Spdr Select Sector Fund Health Care 1.94% 2.08% 1.91% 3.83% 3.48% 1.51% 2.79% 10.80% -7.64% 2.89% 0.01%
KBE State Street Spdr S&p Bank Etf 2.51% 3.70% 4.92% 9.48% 9.05% 10.51% 7.65% 18.07% -5.12% -2.76% 11.44%
KRE State Street Spdr S&p Regional Banking Etf 2.42% 3.76% 4.93% 9.80% 8.93% 9.80% 7.38% 18.36% -2.80% -0.09% 13.57%
XBI State Street Spdr S&p Biotech Etf 7.53% 8.57% 8.48% 10.98% 14.27% 10.57% 12.50% 33.36% -2.47% 18.42% 40.64%
XLRE Real Estate Select Sector Spdr Fund The 1.56% 3.49% 3.76% 6.27% 8.00% 10.41% 7.60% 10.46% -1.46% -5.39% -2.15%
XME State Street Spdr S&p Metals & Mining Etf 4.40% 7.07% 6.12% 8.94% 11.40% 14.76% 23.19% 3.42% -1.22% 10.95% 83.06%
XLI Spdr Select Sector Fund Industrial 3.26% 4.57% 4.90% 9.95% 10.68% 11.47% 10.08% 18.56% 0.16% 1.30% 20.89%
RWR State Street Spdr Dow Jones Reit Etf 1.38% 3.06% 3.33% 5.92% 7.73% 10.04% 8.06% 14.42% 0.33% -1.56% 2.41%
XLP Spdr Select Sector Fund Consumer Staples 0.11% 0.01% -0.76% 1.91% -0.50% 2.96% 0.17% 2.15% 4.65% 3.76% 2.52%
XLU Spdr Select Sector Fund Utilities -0.07% 0.92% 0.77% 2.67% 1.18% 2.02% -6.14% -0.64% 6.96% 4.64% 18.62%
XLB Materials Select Sector Spdr 1.78% 2.68% 2.00% 5.25% 5.95% 4.85% 3.72% 3.93% 7.42% 9.15% 16.14%
XLE Spdr Select Sector Fund Energy Select Sector -1.14% -4.37% -2.91% -7.48% -9.70% -3.74% -7.53% -13.67% 37.72% 37.72% 35.37%
XOP State Street Spdr S&p Oil & Gas Exploration & Prod -1.97% -4.19% -2.77% -9.56% -11.90% -3.92% -9.50% -16.43% 45.43% 39.62% 43.03%
3-Months - Lowest 5 2.97% 3.51% 4.03% 7.42% 9.60% 12.46% 17.03% 16.75% -10.84% -10.09% 11.49%
3-Months - Lowest 10 3.08% 3.92% 4.42% 7.75% 9.17% 10.51% 12.31% 17.48% -7.37% -3.74% 12.10%
3-Months - Highest 5 -0.26% -0.99% -0.73% -1.44% -2.99% 0.43% -3.86% -4.93% 20.44% 18.98% 23.14%
3-Months - Highest 10 1.68% 2.18% 2.29% 3.49% 3.71% 5.94% 4.22% 5.56% 9.75% 11.86% 26.05%


In this case the top five were: XLK, XLF, XLY, XRT and XLC.

The average return looking forward three months was 16.75%. This compares to an average drop of -4.93% for those that had done best leading up to the bottom on 3/30/2026.

Back in the 90s I tested this over a hundred years of history and found it to be consistently true. From then until now in out-of-sample real-time trading it has consistently done well. So yes, it is something worth paying attention to going forward.

Post New | Post Reply | Report Post | Recommend It!
Print the post
Members reply directly to zeelotes here — and replies get answered. Reading is free; so is joining the conversation. Join Shrewd'm »
This community has written 6,115 posts about Mechanical Investing. The article-length ones it recommended most:
Dividend investing · 52 recs · 2025
Non-Mag7 screen · 34 recs · 2025
OT - Div yields and returns · 32 recs · 2024
Using AI to generate backtesting programs · 30 recs · 2025
Rankings for 19Dec2022 · 29 recs · 2022
Unthreaded | Threaded | Whole Thread (20) |


Announcements
Mechanical Investing FAQ
Contact Shrewd'm
Contact the developer of these message boards.

Best Of MI | Best Of | Favourites & Replies | All Boards | Followed Shrewds | Open Questions | Moving a community