Please be patient and understanding when interacting with others, and avoid getting frustrated or upset if someone does not respond to your posts or if a discussion does not go as you expected. Remember that everyone is entitled to express their own perspectives. Furthermore, even when you don't entirely agree, try to benefit in some way from it.
- Manlobbi
Personal Finance Topics / Retirement Investing
No. of Recommendations: 2
I take mine early in the year so that it is close to the date (12/31) that it is based on. If the market goes up over the course of the year, I don't earn money on what I've withdrawn, but if the market goes down, I come out on the winning side of the bet. In the past couple years I've been on the losing side of the wager. I think that will be changing over the next 2-4 years.
No. of Recommendations: 7
On average, the market is higher at the end of the year than the beginning.
I did a quick price-only check, 1985-2023 (39 years).
Of course for total return you also need to add the dividends.
Average price gain from Jan 1 to Dec 31 was 9.3%.
28 years were higher at end-of-year
11 years were lower.
The issue with taking it late in the year is if the market goes down so much that the RMD is a large percent of the diminished account. The 2 largest Jan-Dec losses were -24% and -37% (price-only). The 2 highest were +34% and +31%.
11 of the 39 were +20% or more.
If you take your RMD in-kind by transferring investments from the IRA to a taxable account then it doesn't matter when you do it, because the investment will grow the same no matter which account it is in.
There's a couple of sequencing rules to keep in mind.
You must take your RMD before you can do Roth conversions. (For those who still think Roth conversions are a good idea.)
Qualified charitable distribution (QCD) is only non-taxed if they are RMD.*
-----------------------------------------------------------------
*(controversial & unclear)
"A popular recommendation is to execute a QCD early in the year to avoid any conflict with the “first-dollars-out rule.” The first dollars withdrawn from an IRA are deemed to count toward the RMD. Once an RMD is taken, it cannot be retroactively offset with a later QCD."
No. of Recommendations: 0
Thanks for coming up with the numbers. We do our QCDs out of my wife's IRAs.
No. of Recommendations: 2
My wife and I tend to take ours in November to leave time to fill in any shortage in the original estimates of what's due (and we're cautious about cushions--nothing is complete until it's all complete, and gremlins exist). Exceptions are similar to the one this year: large household expense, so I'll be taking a cash-centered partial RMD out of mine next month (or the following) to cover that cost.
Eric Hines
No. of Recommendations: 5
My folks typically take their RMD in December to maximize time value/ growth of the account and then direct that RMD to help cover their taxes due in April.
