So the big idea that Schumer's being criticized for not implementing is....using a looming shutdown as a leverage attempt? When that's worked out so horribly for everyone that's tried it?

I disagree.

The examples you gave were Republicans supporting positions that were highly unpopular.

There was no support for a wall except for MAGA extremists.

Obamacare was more popular than tax cuts!

Healthcare and education are also quite popular with most Americans.

I think the Democrats should have said they would only support a CR if full funding, including restoring full staffing and offices, for the Social Security Administration, Veterans Affairs, and Medicare. All of these programs are extremely popular with Americans.

This would have forced the Republicans to defend the draconian cuts being made to these programs. Personally, I would have a few more programs, but let’s just stick with these three.

I believe that the vast majority of Americans would strongly support maintaining these programs at current levels and the pressure would be on Republicans to support these programs. In other words, put up or shut up.

As for Trump getting more power, I don’t think you’re paying attention. Trump is already doing anything he wants. He’s ignored orders from federal judges. And mark my words, Trump will at some point ignore rulings from the Supreme Court.

Lastly, a threat of a shutdown over these three programs would show every day Americans that Democrats are willing to fight on their behalf for programs they like. That seems to be something Americans are really looking for and want.