gtr1.net: GTR1 Backtester - Nas100_Mom9_PHL252_SumRanks:
...
Stocks Timed CAGR Untimed post 10/1993...?

Thanks for this interesting sum-of-ranks screen.
I tweaked it to my favorite parameters and 1/3/6/12 RS, from 2/1/1985, 0.25% friction, no timing.
(All the necessary data is available from finviz and barcharts)
I get Average CAGR 29.28% (5 stock)

Looking at the various screens for the cycle with the 25'th percentile returns, with and without timing,
In terms of stdev, MaxDD(12), and Sortino, PHL52 5HTD12 is still the best, then RS52, then sum-of-ranks.

CAGR is in the same order.

With low confidence, it looks like PHL/RS overlaps is worse than all of these.
(Overlaps is tough, since the GTR1 backtest varies the number of stocks from 0 to 5, with an average around 3. I wouldn't like that, so I'd somehow fill in the empty slots with non-overlap picks. I don't know if GTR1 could somehow do this. Absent that, I have no confidence in it.
Sum-of-ranks seems like a better choice for a 3rd screen/portfolio.

Here are the top 10 picks from the GTR1 screener and the picks common of SoR and PHL & RS:

                                        PHL-52    RS52                PHL-52    RS52
PHL-52    RS52      SumRanks            SR Common top 10              SR Common top       
WBD       PLTR      WBD                 WBD       WBD                 WBD       WBD
AVGO      AVGO      MU                  MU        MU                  MU        MU
MU        WBD       AVGO                AVGO      AVGO                AVGO      AVGO
LRCX      MU        LRCX                LRCX      LRCX                LRCX      LRCX
GOOGL     LRCX      GOOGL               GOOGL     GOOGL               GOOGL     
GOOG      GOOGL     GOOG                GOOG      GOOG                          
IDXX      GOOG      INTC                                                        
AMAT      APP       IDXX                IDXX      IDXX                          
KLAC      KLAC      AMAT                AMAT                                    
EA        IDXX      KLAC                KLAC      KLAC                          
CEG       ASML      APP                           APP